CHALLENGE
The pump at the centre of this case study was operating as a booster pump for a desalination plant pumping warm seawater. The CUP split case pump had been in service for over five years and was scheduled for an overhaul due to a drop in efficiency caused by increased running clearances.
The customer had a replacement rotating element to swap out and a full set of replacement bushes ready to go. However, when the top half casing was removed crevice corrosion was apparent on the gasket face. The two regular methods of either replacing the casing or weld repairing it would significantly delay the overhaul.
With a shortage of water in the area, the customer wanted to overhaul the unit in a very short time period to minimize downtime and maintain the supply of desalinated water. replaced by one, and the liquid pumped is passed by five holes that represent an area equivalent to the former version. To prevent corrosion, the bearings were also upgraded to a material with superior wear and abrasion characteristics, plus better chemical compatibility.
SOLUTION
The original pump casing material of Duplex Stainless Steel was selected for a less onerous fluid than was actually found at site. The customer was advised to upgrade any future spares to Super Duplex Stainless Steel, which has a higher pitting resistance equivalent number (PREN) value and is therefore more resistant to crevice corrosion than the original material.
To address the immediate problem, ClydeUnion Pumps undertook a detailed investigation. This revealed that the damage to the casing did not significantly break into the hydraulic passage area, so use of a metal filler compound was an acceptable interim measure. The selection of the correct metal filler for the application was critical to ensure it would withstand the corrosive nature of the warm seawater and the high pressures exerted onto the flange face during normal operation.
OUTCOMES
The repair method used by ClydeUnion Pumps meant that the pump casing could remain in position, and this significantly reduced the repair time of the casing. (It took two days to complete the work, including cure time for the filler.) This meant that the unit could be rebuilt and commissioned within the ten-day turnaround. When the unit was started up, the pump ran with increased efficiency combined with normal vibration and temperature levels.
FINANCIAL ILLUSTRATION
The financial advantage of using this repair method instead of replacing the casing or performing a weld repair was significant in both cost and downtime for the customer. The benefit of utilizing the OEM Aftermarket division is demonstrated in this case study where using the OEM’s product knowledge, Quality Management System and processes returned this pump to service quicker and at lower cost than using traditional repair methods. This fast-track project returned the pump to full operation which in turn protected the customer’s water generation capacity.